Who is the author of 'Excellent Sheep'?

The author of 'Excellent Sheep' is William Deresiewicz.

What are the main themes in 'Excellent Sheep'?

The main themes in 'Excellent Sheep' include Self-Help, Personal Growth, Success Stories.

What genre is 'Excellent Sheep'?

'Excellent Sheep' is categorized as Self-Help.

What is the main argument of 'Excellent Sheep' by William Deresiewicz?

The main argument of 'Excellent Sheep' by William Deresiewicz is that elite education systems, particularly at prestigious universities, produce highly capable but unfulfilled students who conform to societal expectations rather than pursuing their own passions and identities. Deresiewicz critiques the obsession with achievement and the pressures of perfectionism that lead students to prioritize status over genuine intellectual engagement and personal growth. He advocates for a more meaningful educational experience that encourages self-discovery and authentic living.

How does Deresiewicz describe the college experience for students today?

In 'Excellent Sheep,' William Deresiewicz describes the college experience for students today as one that is heavily driven by high expectations and external pressures. He argues that many students are focused on achieving good grades, obtaining prestigious internships, and securing successful careers, often at the expense of genuine personal growth and intellectual engagement. Deresiewicz critiques the system that promotes this competitive atmosphere, suggesting that it leads students to become 'excellent sheep'—highly accomplished but lacking in critical thinking, creativity, and deeper self-understanding. He emphasizes the importance of a college education that fosters individuality, curiosity, and the pursuit of meaningful experiences rather than merely preparing for the workforce.

What themes related to individuality and conformity are explored in the book?

In 'Excellent Sheep', William Deresiewicz explores themes of individuality and conformity by critiquing the pressures faced by students in elite educational institutions. He argues that these environments often promote a rigid form of conformity that discourages genuine self-discovery and personal growth. Deresiewicz delves into how the pursuit of perfection and external validation leads students to adhere to societal expectations rather than fostering their unique identities. He emphasizes the importance of pursuing one's own passions and interests, highlighting how societal norms can stifle creativity and authentic self-expression. Ultimately, the book serves as a call to resist conformity and embrace individuality as a path to true fulfillment.

In what ways does Deresiewicz suggest the education system impacts students' lives and choices?

In 'Excellent Sheep,' William Deresiewicz argues that the education system impacts students' lives and choices in several significant ways. He suggests that: Conformity and Compliance: The system encourages students to conform to societal expectations and prioritize elite achievements, leading to a lack of individuality and self-discovery. Pressure and Stress: The intense focus on grades and prestigious colleges creates immense pressure and stress, which can diminish students' passion for learning and personal growth. Narrow Definitions of Success: Deresiewicz critiques the narrow definition of success that emphasizes high-status careers, often pushing students toward paths they are not genuinely interested in or suited for. Lack of Critical Thinking: The emphasis on rote learning and performance over critical thinking skills can lead to a generation that is less equipped to think independently, challenge norms, or engage meaningfully with societal issues. Isolation and Disconnection: The competitive nature of the education system can create isolation among students rather than fostering genuine connections and collaboration, which are crucial for personal development and mental well-being. Overall, Deresiewicz argues that the education system not only shapes students' academic outcomes but also significantly influences their identities, values, and the choices they make in life.

What are some of the key criticisms of elite education presented in 'Excellent Sheep'?

In 'Excellent Sheep,' William Deresiewicz presents several key criticisms of elite education: Emphasis on Conformity: Deresiewicz argues that elite institutions often promote a culture of conformity rather than creativity and independent thinking. Students are pressured to adhere to a rigid set of expectations regarding academics, extracurriculars, and career pathways. Lack of Genuine Learning: He criticizes the focus on obtaining credentials rather than fostering a deep understanding and love of learning. Students are driven by the desire to achieve high grades and prestigious internships rather than a passion for knowledge. Mental Health Issues: The intense pressure to succeed in elite environments can lead to significant mental health struggles among students, including anxiety and depression. Disconnection from Reality: Deresiewicz contends that the elite education system creates a disconnect between students and the real world. Students become insulated in a bubble that can limit their understanding of broader societal issues. Inequality and Exclusivity: He highlights how elite institutions reinforce social inequalities, catering to privileged backgrounds while neglecting diversity and access for underrepresented groups. Careerism: The book critiques the increasing focus on career preparation, suggesting that it detracts from the development of personal values, ethical reasoning, and a sense of purpose beyond financial success.

Excellent Sheep

In 'Excellent Sheep,' William Deresiewicz explores the pressures faced by today's high-achieving students, revealing how an obsession with success often leads to a life devoid of passion and purpose. He argues that the education system molds them into compliant 'excellent sheep,' prioritizing prestige over authenticity. Through compelling stories and profound insights, Deresiewicz challenges readers to reconsider what it means to thrive in an increasingly competitive world. Can true fulfillment be found outside the narrow paths laid out by society? This thought-provoking examination will leave you questioning the value of conventional success.

By William Deresiewicz

Published: 2014

"The greatest danger is not that we aim too high and miss, but that we aim too low and hit."

Self-Help Personal Growth Success Stories

Start Listening

0:000:00

What Readers Say About This Book

"A groundbreaking manifesto for people searching for the kind of insight on leading, thinking, and living that elite schools should be--but aren't--providing"--

The Mike & Casey Show

Dive into captivating book discussions with our expert hosts

Key Points from Excellent Sheep

In "Excellent Sheep," William Deresiewicz presents a powerful critique of the education system, arguing that it fosters a generation of 'excellent sheep'—students who achieve at high levels but do so primarily by conforming to societal expectations rather than pursuing intrinsic passions. For instance, he illustrates this phenomenon through anecdotes of Ivy League students who have accomplished remarkable feats in academics and extracurricular activities but ultimately feel empty and disengaged, lacking a genuine sense of purpose. Deresiewicz highlights the consequences of a meritocratic culture that equates success with attending prestigious colleges and obtaining prestigious jobs, often at the expense of personal fulfillment and critical thinking. This argument is significant as it calls attention to a pervasive issue in modern education—where the pursuit of grades and accolades trumps personal development and self-awareness. It connects to broader themes in the book that challenge the capitalist ethos of success and the pressure to conform, advocating instead for a more holistic approach to education that prioritizes character formation and the cultivation of one's individual passions. Ultimately, Deresiewicz encourages readers to re-evaluate what it means to lead a successful life, urging a departure from superficial measures of achievement to a journey of self-discovery and fulfillment.

About the Author

William Deresiewicz

William Deresiewicz is an acclaimed American essayist, critic, and author known for his insightful commentary on education, culture, and society. He gained prominence with his book 'Excellent Sheep: The Miseducation of the American Elite and the Way to a Meaningful Life,' where he critiques the pressures of elite education and advocates for a more fulfilling approach to learning. His other notable works include 'Solitude and Leadership,' an essay widely discussed in educational and professional circles, and 'The Death of Criticism,' which explores the role of criticism in art and society. Deresiewicz's writing style is characterized by its intellectual rigor, accessibility, and depth, making complex ideas relatable to a broad audience.

Book Details

Key information about the book.

Authors: William Deresiewicz
Published: January 2014
Publisher: Simon and Schuster
ISBN: 1476702721
Language: English
Pages: 272
Genres: Self-HelpPersonal GrowthSuccess Stories

Purchase Options

Buy on Amazon

Buy via BookShop

Support local bookstores: BookShop gives a portion of each sale to independent bookshops!

Similar books you might like →

The Blessing of a B Minus

Wendy Mogel

12 Rules for Life

Jordan B. Peterson

Mistakes Were Made (but Not by Me)

Elliot Aronson, Carol Tavris

Redirect

Timothy D. Wilson

Finding Your Way to Change

Allan Zuckoff, Bonnie Gorscak

Managing Oneself

Peter Ferdinand Drucker

Love Warrior

Glennon Doyle, Glennon Doyle Melton

The Purpose Driven Life

Rick Warren

Showing 8 of 30 similar books

Take your reading experience to the next level

Download our mobile app to enjoy your favorite books on the go. Get access to exclusive features, offline listening, and personalized recommendations.

Book Collections you might like →

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's Book Recommendations

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, also known as AOC, is a U.S. Congresswoman representing New York's 14th district. She gained national attention after winning her seat in 2018 at the age of 29, making her one of the youngest women ever elected to Congress. Ocasio-Cortez is known for her progressive policies, advocating for issues such as Medicare for All, climate change action, and economic justice. She has become a prominent figure within the Democratic Party and uses social media to engage with constituents and the public. Her rise from grassroots activism to Congress has inspired many young people to get involved in politics.

View Collection

Abi Tyas Tunggal's Book Recommendations

Abi Tyas Tunggal is a distinguished author known for his impactful contributions to contemporary literature and digital content. He has garnered acclaim for his insightful storytelling and adept handling of complex themes, resonating with a diverse readership. Tunggal's work often explores the intersections of technology, society, and human experience, making him a prominent voice in modern narrative arts. Beyond his literary achievements, he is also recognized for his innovative use of digital platforms to engage with and expand his audience. Tunggal continues to influence the literary landscape with his thought-provoking and accessible writing.

View Collection

Graham Stephan's Book Recommendations

Graham Stephan is a prominent real estate investor, YouTuber, and personal finance guru known for his insightful content on financial independence and investment strategies. He began his career in real estate at the age of 18 and quickly rose to prominence, amassing a multi-million-dollar portfolio. Stephan's YouTube channel, which boasts millions of subscribers, offers accessible and practical advice on budgeting, saving, and investing, earning him widespread acclaim and a dedicated following. In addition to his online presence, he has been featured in numerous high-profile publications and media outlets, solidifying his status as an influential figure in personal finance education. Through his work, Stephan has empowered countless individuals to take control of their finances and pursue financial freedom.

View Collection

Brian Armstrong's Book Recommendations

Brian Armstrong is a renowned entrepreneur and author best known for co-founding and leading Coinbase, a major cryptocurrency exchange. His literary contributions include insightful writings on the future of digital currencies and blockchain technology. Armstrong's work has been pivotal in demystifying complex financial systems for a broader audience. Beyond his business acumen, his thought leadership in publications and public speaking engagements has cemented his status as a key voice in the fintech revolution. His dedication to innovation continues to influence the trajectory of global financial systems.

View Collection

Ashton Kutcher's Book Recommendations

Ashton Kutcher is an accomplished actor, producer, and entrepreneur best known for his roles in popular television series such as "That '70s Show" and "Two and a Half Men." While not primarily recognized for contributions to literature, Kutcher has significantly impacted the tech industry through his venture capital firm, A-Grade Investments, which has funded successful startups like Airbnb and Uber. Additionally, he co-founded the media company Katalyst, which has produced various digital content. Kutcher is also an active philanthropist, co-founding the DNA Foundation, now known as Thorn, which focuses on combating human trafficking and the sexual exploitation of children. His diverse ventures reflect a commitment to innovation, social good, and entertainment.

View Collection

Derek Sivers's Book Recommendations

Derek Sivers is an entrepreneur, author, and founder of CD Baby, one of the first online platforms that allowed independent musicians to sell their music directly to fans. Sivers is known for his unconventional approach to business and life, advocating for simplicity, focus, and self-reliance. After selling CD Baby, Sivers has become a sought-after speaker and writer, sharing insights on entrepreneurship, creativity, and personal development. His books, including Anything You Want, provide practical advice for living a meaningful, purpose-driven life. Sivers’ minimalist and thoughtful approach has made him a respected figure in the entrepreneurial community.

View Collection

Alex Hormozi's Book Recommendations

Alex Hormozi is a celebrated entrepreneur, author, and founder of Acquisition.com, a company dedicated to helping businesses scale efficiently. He gained prominence with his best-selling book "Gym Launch Secrets," which provides a blueprint for fitness entrepreneurs to grow their businesses. Hormozi is also known for "The Million Dollar Offers" book, where he shares strategies on creating irresistible offers that drive sales. His work has significantly impacted the business community, providing practical insights and actionable advice for entrepreneurs. Through his books and business ventures, Hormozi continues to inspire and guide countless individuals on their journey to success.

View Collection

Daymond John's Book Recommendations

Daymond John is a successful entrepreneur, motivational speaker, and author, best known as a star investor on the television show "Shark Tank." He founded the urban apparel company FUBU, which grew into a multi-billion dollar brand. As an author, John has penned several influential books, including the New York Times bestsellers "The Power of Broke" and "Rise and Grind," which offer insights into entrepreneurship and personal development. His work emphasizes the importance of resilience, hard work, and creativity in achieving success. Through his books and public speaking, John has inspired countless individuals to pursue their business dreams and overcome obstacles.

View Collection

Showing 8 of 10 related collections

“The greatest danger is not that we aim too high and miss, but that we aim too low and hit.”

Excellent Sheep

By William Deresiewicz

Frequently Asked Questions

Explore Our Catalogue

Discover a world of knowledge through our extensive collection of book summaries.

Key Points from Excellent Sheep

In "Excellent Sheep," William Deresiewicz presents a powerful critique of the education system, arguing that it fosters a generation of 'excellent sheep'—students who achieve at high levels but do so primarily by conforming to societal expectations rather than pursuing intrinsic passions. For instance, he illustrates this phenomenon through anecdotes of Ivy League students who have accomplished remarkable feats in academics and extracurricular activities but ultimately feel empty and disengaged, lacking a genuine sense of purpose. Deresiewicz highlights the consequences of a meritocratic culture that equates success with attending prestigious colleges and obtaining prestigious jobs, often at the expense of personal fulfillment and critical thinking. This argument is significant as it calls attention to a pervasive issue in modern education—where the pursuit of grades and accolades trumps personal development and self-awareness. It connects to broader themes in the book that challenge the capitalist ethos of success and the pressure to conform, advocating instead for a more holistic approach to education that prioritizes character formation and the cultivation of one's individual passions. Ultimately, Deresiewicz encourages readers to re-evaluate what it means to lead a successful life, urging a departure from superficial measures of achievement to a journey of self-discovery and fulfillment.

Excellent Sheep

Start Listening

What Readers Say About This Book

The Mike & Casey Show

Key Points from Excellent Sheep

About the Author

William Deresiewicz

Book Details

Purchase Options

Similar books you might like →

The Blessing of a B Minus

12 Rules for Life

Mistakes Were Made (but Not by Me)

Redirect

Finding Your Way to Change

Managing Oneself

Love Warrior

The Purpose Driven Life

Take your reading experience to the next level

Book Collections you might like →

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's Book Recommendations

Abi Tyas Tunggal's Book Recommendations

Graham Stephan's Book Recommendations

Brian Armstrong's Book Recommendations

Ashton Kutcher's Book Recommendations

Derek Sivers's Book Recommendations

Alex Hormozi's Book Recommendations

Daymond John's Book Recommendations

Frequently Asked Questions

Explore Our Catalogue

Genres

Genres

Genres

Featured Collections

The Mike & Casey Show

Key Points from Excellent Sheep

Frequently Asked Questions